Best Property Managers in Sheffield

22 companies listed · all 22 in Sheffield · 8 open weekends · 16 rated 4.5+

Data verified October 21, 2026

Ilet4you Limited

Ilet4you Limited

4.8 85 reviews
“The best letting agent in town was let down by others, but here, it's different. The staff is extremely helpful. They currently manage 35 of my properties.”
Prices online
60 Page Hall Rd, Sheffield S4 8GW
i
2roost

2roost

4.3 489 reviews
“I have found 2Roost to be extremely professional & diluting their dealings with me & our tenants. Nothing is ever too much trouble. I have experienced a real variety of letting agents but can't fault 2Roost & give no hesitation in recommending them. If I were to rent a property in the future I would use them again.”
Prices online
27 Main St, Swallownest, Sheffield S26 4TZ
i
Butlers Estate Agents

Butlers Estate Agents

4.6 92 reviews
“I used Butlers Estate Agency as a lettings agent initially, They were very thorough with their vetting processes, And committed to finding suitable tenants for the property, Butlers provided Great correspondence throughout the whole process of letting the property to tenants, I never encountered any problems whatsoever and was very grateful that Butlers was managing the property. Due to David and Leannes professional and committed approach I instructed Butlers to sell the property when the time was right, Again they never disappointed, with regular discussions and updates I felt very satisfied that I had relied on Butlers to deliver exceptional service and sell the property. Highly recommend the whole Team from Butlers Estate Agency as a letting Agent and an Estate Agent, Butlers are a great, honest and reliable Agency who I would use again in the future.”
Family-owned
Spring House, Mosborough, 60 High St, Mosborough, Sheffield S20 5AH
i
The Pennine Property Group

The Pennine Property Group

4.8 64 reviews
“I have had an outstanding experience with Pennine Property Group and would not hesitate to recommend their services. Lizzie and her team managed my rental property for over five years with exceptional professionalism, reliability, and care. They consistently provided clear communication, efficient maintenance management, and sound advice, giving me complete peace of mind as a landlord. When I decided to sell the property, it was an easy decision to continue working with Pennine. The sales process was handled seamlessly — from valuation through to completion — with regular updates and expert guidance throughout. Lizzie and her team demonstrated a thorough understanding of the local market and a genuine commitment to achieving the best outcome for their clients. Their blend of professionalism, transparency, and personal service truly sets them apart. I am deeply appreciative of their support and would highly recommend Pennine Property Group to anyone seeking first-class property management or sales services.”
12 St Mary's St, Penistone, Sheffield S36 6DT
i
Horizon Lets

Horizon Lets

4.9 82 reviews
“Rented from Chris at horizon lets for 5 years , hes an excellent landlord , always responded promptly if any repairs were needed and he always had a solution the same day , highly recommended.”
Since 2017
Aizlewoods Mill, Nursery St, Sheffield S3 8GG
i
JC Sales & Lettings

JC Sales & Lettings

4.9 133 reviews
“Great experience, They are professional, fully compliant with all regulations, and consistently deliver excellent results. Communication is clear and timely, making the whole process smooth and stress-free. Highly recommend if you're looking for a reliable letting agent who gets the job done right. A cut above the rest.”
Since 2022
33 Townhead Rd, Dore, Sheffield S17 3GD
i

Listed for property owners in and around Sheffield, these 22 companies let and manage rented property. Whether a firm offers full management or tenant find only, and which schemes it names, is taken from its own website, with ratings and quotes drawn from public reviews.

Hiring a letting agent in Sheffield

All 22 companies we list here are in Sheffield itself. We have 44 companies in Sheffield on file; this page shows the highest-rated 22. The companies on this page are rated from 4.1 to 5.0 across 2,326 reviews; 16 have 50 or more reviews and 16 are rated 4.5 or higher. The topics that come up most in reviews of the companies on this page are "communication", "professional" and "price".

Horizon Management

Horizon Management

4.4 87 reviews
“I've personally worked with Chris & the Horizon team on several occasions & they have all been great. Chris is very professional and dedicated, happy to recommend and refer for block management 👏🏼”
Aizlewoods Mill, Nursery St, Sheffield S3 8GG
i
MBA Lettings & Property Management

MBA Lettings & Property Management

4.5 69 reviews
“No words can express how great MBA Lettings has always been. They've been brilliant from start to finish, always so responsive, helpful, and easy to deal with. Any questions or issues I've had have been handled quickly and professionally, pretty much same day. A special mention to Mick, who is an absolute gem! He's been incredibly helpful, friendly, and always goes the extra mile. I'd definitely recommend MBA Lettings to anyone looking for a reliable and professional letting agent in Sheffield, student or working professional.”
15+ years
221 Fulwood Rd, Sheffield S10 3BA
i
Shefflets

Shefflets

4.3 152 reviews
“Excellent letting agent, they always were on the ball for any maintenance requests that came through and were very good overall during my tenancy, highly recommend!”
Since 2008Family-owned
953 Ecclesall Rd, Sheffield S11 8TN
i
M3 Lettings Ltd

M3 Lettings Ltd

4.3 96 reviews
“Great letting agents. Couldn't ask for anyone better to have and thank you to Jack and Michael who were always there to help solve any issues or questions we had over the past 2 years. Thank you for having us guys”
Since 2006
74 Barber Rd, Sheffield S10 1EE
i
Merali Lettings

Merali Lettings

4.5 55 reviews
“They have been my landlord for 14 years in 2 different properties and they have been brilliant. Any repairs have been dealt with immediately and the people in the office are always really helpful”
209-211 Whitham Rd, Sheffield S10 2SP
i
United Homes

United Homes

4.8 65 reviews
“United Homes have helped us sell a house and also find a rental. Sam, Dean and the team have been helpful, trustworthy and responsive throughout. Jill took the time to take some great photos and did a great write up of our property. A pleasure to deal with!”
Since 2011
17B Langsett Rd S, Oughtibridge, Sheffield S35 0GY
i
P J Properties

P J Properties

4.8 84 reviews
“We rented a student flat with PJ's, never had any problems with them. Any problems we had were dealt with quickly, very pleasant team, quick to respond to emails. Would highly recommend to any students looking for accommodation.”
194 Whitham Rd, Broomhill, Sheffield S10 2SS
i
Spencer. the Estate Agent

Spencer. the Estate Agent

4.8 406 reviews
“I've just finished a two-year tenancy with Spencers Estate Agents and had a great experience. The team were organised and professional throughout, and always quick to respond to any questions. I dealt mostly with Lynn, who was incredibly helpful and responsive. She made everything straightforward and couldn't have done more for me. Having had poor experiences with letting agents in the past, I was initially a little worried, but Spencers were excellent from start to finish.”
469 Ecclesall Rd, Sharrow, Sheffield S11 8PP
i
Swots Student Accommodation

Swots Student Accommodation

4.8 140 reviews
“I rented with swots for 2 years while at Sheffield uni and couldn't have asked for better landlords! Communal areas in the house had been renovated to a high standard just before we moved in and new bedroom furniture provided which was a bonus. The team responded quickly to any issues we had in the house so would definitely recommend swots to other Sheffield students!”
34A Beech Hill Rd, Sheffield S10 2SB
i
Butchers Estate Agents

Butchers Estate Agents

4.8 59 reviews
“Absolutely brilliant team , our property valued and put on market same day and sold the day after . Holly really made the process go smoothly keeping us up to date every step of the way . Would highly recommend.”
Since 2009Family-owned
2, Crown House, Shrewsbury Rd, Penistone, Sheffield S36 6DY
i
Movr Group

Movr Group

5.0 26 reviews
“I have absolute nothing bad to say about this business or Mark himself. Mark became our landlord after our previous landlords decided to sell - this was a very stressful situation with myself being heavily pregnant at the time. Mark came to have a look around our house and in doing so, played football with our son and commended us on our home. A few weeks later Mark came to check our chimney with one of his builders and bought us a gift as I had given birth 3 days prior. While Mark has put our rent up to reflect prices in our area, we found it to be a reasonable and still affordable increase and had no issue with this. Mark is very personable, professional, respectful and also very compassionate person. 100% recommend. 😊”
Since 2022Prices online
74a John St, Highfield, Sheffield S2 4QU
i
Cavendish Peaks Accommodation Management

Cavendish Peaks Accommodation Management

5.0 16 reviews
“In our experience, Cavendish Peaks has proven to be a highly professional and receptive company that provides quality support for its customers, prioritising their comfort foremost. We stayed in one of their properties for about 2 months, and it was not only comfortable but, one of our best stays. We felt truly at home away from home. Despite the strange times we are in right now, the staff were incredibly friendly and warm, and provided us with help regarding any questions we had about our stay and was always willing and open to go above and beyond to help us. We highly recommend Cavendish Peaks properties for their amazing service.”
Since 2019Family-ownedPrices online
Cubo, 38 Carver St, Sheffield S1 4FS
i
Prop Home

Prop Home

4.2 26 reviews
“So this is first time we have rented through PropHome but are impressed by the quality and services offered by this letting agency. As often, when we moved in the property had some issues with furniture from previous tenant but Prop home was quick to acknowledge our requests and replaced the furniture which was worn out and broken with high quality stuff to our pleasure. The communication is very good and effective with the agents. We are happy and would consider extending our tenancy further with Prop Home. Thanks Dr Farooqi and Prof Harris 11 Mann Island Liverpool”
Since 2021Prices online
1 Concourse Way, Sheffield City Centre, Sheffield S1 2BJ
i
WH Properties

WH Properties

4.8 46 reviews
“I used WH Properties for 4 years while at university. They were always very prompt at addressing any maintenance issues, we loved the properties, and were very happy with them overall!”
11 Commonside, Sheffield S10 1GA
i
Hub Site Services

Hub Site Services

4.7 31 reviews
“We have used Hub Site Services on several occasions now. I can honestly say that all staff are very professional, polite and go that little bit further to aim for a very high standard. The most recent job being removal of the fitness room floor, removal of the floor electrical sockets, the floor then re-skimmed and new flooring laid. All this was completed within 3 days. Very please with the finished job. Thanks guys!! Highly recommend!! :)”
Suite 37, Quadrant Business Centre, 99 Parkway Ave, Sheffield S9 4WG
i
R D B Estates Ltd

R D B Estates Ltd

4.1 23 reviews
“RDB Estates Ltd have been our managing agents for our buy-to-let property in Mansfield for the past 15 years. Richard has given us excellent service, always responding to emails immediately, and on the few occasions where we have had issues, he has always gone above and beyond to resolve the issue. We can honestly say we cant remember the last time he had a price increase and we have absolutely no hesitation in recommending his services. More recently we have used Richard for letting our but-to-let and again he has given excellent service. We started to use Richard for letting approximately 5 years ago and since we have switched to his services we have not had one void period. We recently decided to sell our buy-to-let and Richard very kindly put us in touch with another landlord who is seriously interested in buying it. So again we have absolutely no hesitation in recommending his services for the letting side of his business.”
Unit 7, Riverside Park, Sheaf Gardens, Duchess Rd, Highfield, Sheffield S2 4BL
i
HomeProperty ManagersEnglandSheffield, ENG

Compare Property Managers in Sheffield

The same listings as above, ordered by how much each states and how well it is reviewed. Each cell is what the business states itself.

Show only
JC Sales & Lettings4.9 · 133 reviews
Since 2022
Movr Group5.0 · 26 reviews
Since 2022
United Homes4.8 · 65 reviews
Since 2011
Butchers Estate Agents4.8 · 59 reviews
Since 2009
Cavendish Peaks Accommodation Management5.0 · 16 reviews
Since 2019
Horizon Lets4.9 · 82 reviews
Since 2017
2roost4.3 · 489 reviews
Shefflets4.3 · 152 reviews
Since 2008
Spencer. the Estate Agent4.8 · 406 reviews
Ilet4you Limited4.8 · 85 reviews
The Pennine Property Group4.8 · 64 reviews
Prop Home4.2 · 26 reviews
Since 2021
Butlers Estate Agents4.6 · 92 reviews
MBA Lettings & Property Management4.5 · 69 reviews
15+ years
M3 Lettings Ltd4.3 · 96 reviews
Since 2006
Swots Student Accommodation4.8 · 140 reviews
P J Properties4.8 · 84 reviews
WH Properties4.8 · 46 reviews
Hub Site Services4.7 · 31 reviews
Merali Lettings4.5 · 55 reviews
Horizon Management4.4 · 87 reviews
R D B Estates Ltd4.1 · 23 reviews

Where a cell is empty, the listing does not state it.

How we build this list

No one pays to be hereNo business pays us. A listing, a higher spot or a Best of award cannot be bought.
Checked before listedPermanently closed businesses, call centres posing as local trades and duplicate branches are kept off our pages.
Real customer reviewsEvery review was left by a customer on the company's public listing. We write none and accept none from businesses.
Rechecked every seasonEvery listing is checked again about every three months, once a season: hours, phone, website, reviews.

For Property Managers we compared 1,125 businesses in and around Sheffield. Each gets a score from its customer rating, how many reviews back it up and how complete its profile is. Best of award holders come first, then businesses in Sheffield, then those in nearby towns. Within each group, the higher score goes first.

Is this page useful? Yes
No
Is there anything wrong with this page?
Back To Top